Explore histories of migration, citizenship and belonging in Germany and the U.S. over the centuries.
The view of migrants and refugees as criminals gained traction in Germany after a large number of complaints of robbery and sexual assault were reported from the central train station during Cologne’s 2015/2016 New Year’s celebration.
On January 1st 2016, police confirmed receiving 1,200 complaints all stemming from the area immediately surrounding the Cologne central train station. Nearly 500 of the claims were of sexual assault, with victims surrounded and attacked by groups of men. While the crowded conditions of the night prevented clear identification of the attackers, there was a consensus that the men were of North African or Arab descent and speculated to be migrants or asylum seekers. Facing public pressure, parliament soon passed a “no means no” law that broadened the definition of sexual assault, lessened the burden of proof to file a claim, and imposed stricter punishments for offenders.
Though heralded as a step forward in combating sexual violence, many criticized the context in which the law was passed. The debate that came after the Cologne New Years Eve attacks followed the common narrative of scapegoating the “other” for the ills of society. The new law was already on the pipeline for a vote, however the attacks in Cologne expedited its passage and prompted officials to include strict deportation requirements for asylum seekers convicted of sexual assault. Utilizing thinly veiled xenophobic rhetoric, right-wing groups touted the assaults at Cologne as an example of the social decay imminent if Germany continued along Merkel’s immigration policy.
Feminist groups campaigned against the co-opting of violence against women as a political tool to further anti-immigration platforms using the hashtag #ausnahmslos (no excuses). They were quick to point out that sexual violence was not a phenomenon imported by migrants, but rather a pervasive problem in German society, evidenced by the 58% of women who have experienced sexual harassment according to a 2006 study by the German Federal Ministry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth.
Nonetheless, the Cologne assaults caused a backlash against Germany’s approach to immigration. A few days after the assaults, a group of migrant men were beaten near the Cologne train station and hospitalized with severe injuries. In a neighboring town, an asylum shelter was arsoned. In the following New Year’s celebration, racial profiling was used by police to search hundreds of men of color, ban various from the premises and detain some.
Almost one year after the Cologne attacks, Germany still struggles with refugee integration. The Journal. December 17, 2016. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Cologne Police ‘right to target North Africans’ at New Year. BBC. January 2, 2018. Date accessed: August 14, 2018.
Health, well-being and personal safety of women in Germany — A representative study of violence against women in Germany. Federal Ministry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth, 2006. Date accessed: August 21, 2018.
Yermi Brenner, Katrin Ohlendorf. Time for the facts. What do we know about Cologne four months later?. The Correspondent. May 2, 2016. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Melissa Eddy. Germany Passes ‘No Means No’ Law After Cologne Attacks. The New York Times. July 7, 2016. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Rick Noack. 2,000 men ‘sexually assaulted 1,200 women’ at Cologne New Year’s Eve party. The Independent. July 11, 2016. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Combating Violence Against Women: Germany. European Institute for Gender Equality. Date accessed: August 15, 2018.
German Ruling Party Pushes for Tougher Asylum Law. Deutsche Welle. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Zach Beauchamp. The Cologne sexual assaults at the center of German politics, explained. Vox. Date accessed: August 6, 2018.
Ausnahmslos. Against Sexual violence and racism. Always and everywhere.. #ausnahmslos. Date accessed: October 4, 2018.